Firm Cheese

Discover artisan firm cheeses selected for their rich flavor, satisfying texture, and exceptional craftsmanship. Explore expertly curated farmstead and specialty cheeses from acclaimed producers in the U.S. and beyond.

Clear all

  • Gift-Worthy Cheese

    Ready Made Gift Boxes

    Perfect for the Cheese lover in your life.

    Shop Now
  • Manchego 1605.
    Queseria 1605
    Manchego 1605
    From $21.50
    From $21.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Sheep
    Origin: Spain
    Age: 6-8 months
  • Comté.
    Marcel Petite/Essex Street Cheese
    Comté
    From $19.50
    From $19.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: France
    Age: 14-18 months
  • Shelburne Farms Two Year Cheddar.
    Shelburne Farms
    Shelburne Farms Two Year Cheddar
    From $13.50
    From $13.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: United States
    Age: 2 years
  • Pitchfork Cheddar.
    Sold out
    Trethowan Brothers
    Pitchfork Cheddar
    From $24.00
    From $24.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: England
    Age: 12-18 months
  • Cabot Clothbound Cheddar.
    Jasper Hill Farm
    Cabot Clothbound Cheddar
    From $16.00
    From $16.00 $0.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: United States
    Age: 9-13 months
  • Verano.
    Vermont Shepherd
    Verano
    From $22.00
    From $22.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Sheep
    Origin: United States
    Age: 4-6 months
  • Schnebelhorn.
    Kaserei Bütschwil
    Schnebelhorn
    From $18.00
    From $18.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: Switzerland
    Age: 8-9 months
  • Chällerhocker.
    Käserei Tufertschwil
    Chällerhocker
    From $18.50
    From $18.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: Switzerland
    Age: 10+ months
  • Kirkham's Lancashire.
    Sold out
    Mrs. Kirkhams
    Kirkham's Lancashire
    From $24.00
    From $24.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: England
    Age: 12 months
  • Ossau Iraty.
    Agour
    Ossau Iraty

    From $20.00
    From $20.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Sheep
    Origin: France
    Age: 5-6 months
  • Sparkenhoe Mature Red Leicester.
    Leicestershire Handmade Cheese
    Sparkenhoe Mature Red Leicester
    From $22.00
    From $22.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: England
    Age: 18 months
  • Brabander.
    Fromagerie L'Amuse
    Brabander
    From $19.00
    From $19.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Goat
    Origin: The Netherlands
    Age: 8-10 months
  • Wrångebäck.
    Almnäs Bruk
    Wrångebäck
    From $18.50
    From $18.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: Sweden
    Age: 14 months
  • Pleasant Ridge Reserve.
    Uplands Cheese Company
    Pleasant Ridge Reserve
    From $18.50
    From $18.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: United States
    Age: 9-10 months

  • SUBSCRIPTION BOXES

    MONTHLY CHEESE

    Pick up for free in store, or have it delivered directly to your door.

    SHOP NOW
  • Montgomery’s Cheddar.
    Montgomery's
    Montgomery’s Cheddar
    From $20.50
    From $20.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: England
    Age: 12-18 months
  • Pecorino Tartufo.
    Various Producers
    Pecorino Tartufo
    From $19.00
    From $19.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Sheep
    Origin: Italy
    Age: 4-5 months
  • Hornbacher.
    Michael Spycher
    Hornbacher
    From $22.50
    From $22.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: Switzerland
    Age: 12 months
  • Pecorino Calcagno.
    Casa Madaio
    Pecorino Calcagno
    From $17.50
    From $17.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Sheep
    Origin: Italy
    Age: 12 months
  • Comté Sagesse
    Sold out
    Marcel Petite/Essex Street Cheese
    Comté Sagesse
    From $24.00
    From $24.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: France
    Age: 24 months
  • Beaufort d'Alpage
    Joseph Paccard
    Beaufort d'Alpage
    From $22.50
    From $22.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: France
    Age: 16-18 months
  • Our House Fondue Blend
    Sold out
    Fairfield Cheese
    Our House Fondue Blend
    $39.99
    $39.99
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: Switzerland
  • Cachalot.
    Sold out
    Mystic Cheese Company
    Finback
    From $14.50
    From $14.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: United States
    Age: 3-4 months

  • FREE PICK UP

    ON ALL ORDERS

    Available to suit you, select your time and date at checkout.

  • Appleby's Cheshire.
    Sold out
    Appleby Family
    Appleby's Cheshire
    From $23.50
    From $23.50
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: England
    Age: 4 months
  • Gruyère 1655.
    Bergkäserai Fritzenhaus
    Gruyère AOP
    From $19.00
    From $19.00
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Cow
    Origin: Switzerland
    Age: 14 months
  • Fulvi Pecorino Romano.
    Fulvi
    Fulvi Pecorino Romano
    From $13.99
    From $13.99
    Type: Firm
    Milk: Sheep
    Origin: Italy
    Age: 10-12 months